Skip to content

Circular resolutions with Skribble or DocuSign?

—10 min read

A fountain pen and a violet check mark on two sheets of paper lying side by side

A Swiss board of directors does not need an e-signature to pass a circular resolution electronically. Since 1 January 2023, Art. 713 para. 2 no. 3 of the Code of Obligations (CO) allows resolutions in writing on paper or in electronic form, and for electronic resolutions no signature is required unless the board has decided otherwise in writing. A qualified electronic signature (QES) still matters in two places: where your own regulations demand a signature, and where a document goes to the commercial register.

Who wrote this post?

Konsaro wrote this post and sells a board portal with circular resolutions, so we have an interest. Skribble and DocuSign are signature services, not board portals. We describe them from their own websites, checked on 29 October 2026 unless a different date is given, and we say what they do well. Have your own process reviewed by a lawyer.

What exactly does Art. 713 CO say about form and signature?

Art. 713 para. 2 CO lists three ways of deciding: at a meeting with a venue, by electronic means (applying Arts. 701c to 701e CO), or in writing on paper or in electronic form, "unless a member requests oral deliberation". The same paragraph then says: for a resolution passed electronically no signature is required, subject to a different written rule of the board. We read the article on fedlex on 29 October 2026 (version in force from 1 October 2026).

Three consequences follow. First, the signature question is a matter for the board itself: if the organisational regulations or an earlier board decision say that circular resolutions must be signed, that rule still applies. Second, the paper route is unchanged and a handwritten signature remains the normal way to confirm a paper resolution. Third, the minutes are a separate duty: Art. 713 para. 3 CO requires minutes of deliberations and resolutions, signed by the chair and the person keeping them.

What is the difference between simple, advanced and qualified signatures?

Swiss law knows several levels. Only the qualified electronic signature with a qualified time stamp is put on the same footing as a handwritten signature, in Art. 14 para. 2bis CO, which also reserves different statutory or contractual rules. DocuSign's legality page for Switzerland, last updated 15 January 2026 according to the page, lists the same four categories (electronic, advanced, regulated and qualified) and states that only the qualified one is deemed equivalent to a handwritten signature.

Signature levels and where they matter for a board
LevelWhat it provesTypical use for a board
Simple (SES)A person clicked or typed; weak proof of identityAcknowledging a motion by email, where no signature is required
Advanced (AES)Linked to the signer and detects later changesInternal documents where the board wants stronger proof than an email
Qualified (QES) with qualified time stampEquivalent to a handwritten signature (Art. 14 para. 2bis CO)Documents with a form requirement; electronic filings with the commercial register; boards that have decided to require it

Skribble states on its Swiss home page that users sign with the qualified electronic signature, valid under ZertES and eIDAS, and on its English pricing page it lists simple, advanced and qualified signatures. Skribble says it is hosted in Switzerland and ISO 27001 certified. DocuSign's German product page for the QES (checked 27 October 2026) describes an eIDAS-compliant QES; if you need a QES under Swiss law, ask the vendor which certificate and trust service provider it uses.

When does a circular resolution still need a QES?

Whenever a rule outside Art. 713 CO asks for one. The common cases are the commercial register and your own regulations.

  • Commercial register: electronic filings must be signed with a QES with a qualified time stamp (Art. 18 para. 4 Commercial Register Ordinance), and exhibits submitted in electronic form must carry one as well (Art. 20 para. 2). A board resolution that is an exhibit for a register entry therefore needs a QES if you file it electronically. Whether a particular register office accepts an unsigned electronic circular resolution on paper is a question for the office or your lawyer.
  • Own regulations: older organisational regulations often say that circular resolutions need the signature of every member. Check them before you drop signatures.
  • Third parties: a bank, landlord or counterparty may ask for a signed extract of the resolution. That is a contract matter, not a requirement of Art. 713 CO.
  • Other bodies: Art. 713 CO is the rule for the board of directors of a company limited by shares. A GmbH, association or foundation board follows its own statutes and regulations.

What do Skribble and DocuSign do well, and where do they stop?

Both are strong at one job: getting a finished document signed with the right level of signature.

  • Skribble: signing up to the QES under ZertES and eIDAS; Swiss hosting; a 14-day free trial without credit card (Swiss home page and pricing page, 29 October 2026). The pricing page lists a Starter plan paid per signature, Team at EUR 23 and Pro at EUR 36 per user and month excluding VAT with annual billing, and a one-time QES identification fee of EUR 24.50 or CHF 22.50 excluding VAT. Prices change; check the page.
  • DocuSign: a detailed Swiss legality guide and a QES product page; global trust service providers; pricing is not on the pages we checked.
  • Neither product page mentions circular resolutions, deadlines, quorum or a decisions register. That is not a criticism: they are signature tools.

A signature tool therefore answers who signed this PDF. A circular resolution has more questions: who got the motion and when, who answered, did anyone ask for a discussion, what is the result, where is it recorded.

What does a clean circular resolution process look like, with or without a signature?

  1. Draft the motion as resolution text that stands on its own, with the reasons and attached documents.
  2. Send it to all members at the same time, with a reply deadline and a clear way to ask for oral deliberation.
  3. Collect each answer (yes, no, abstain) in a form you can prove later: a signed PDF, an email thread or a portal record.
  4. After the deadline, the chair states the result. If a member asked for deliberation, the matter goes to a meeting.
  5. File motion, answers and result together and enter them in the minutes or the decisions register.

The signature, if you want one, is only step 3. The other four steps are what an auditor, a successor on the board or a court would look at.

What does this look like for Muster AG?

Muster AG is an invented company. Its five-member board wants to approve a new signing authority between two meetings. Its organisational regulations, from 2019, say that circular resolutions must be signed by all members.

Muster AG: three options
OptionWhat happensResult
A. Keep the old ruleEach member signs the PDF with a QES via Skribble or DocuSign; the secretary collects five signed filesValid under the board's own rule; slow, and the deadline and the discussion option are managed in email
B. Change the rule firstThe board decides in a meeting, in writing, that electronic circular resolutions need no signature; later motions are voted in a portalMatches Art. 713 para. 2 no. 3 CO; the change itself is minuted
C. Keep the signature for some casesRegulations: no signature for ordinary resolutions, QES for resolutions that are filed with the commercial registerSignature only where an outside rule asks for it

Option C is what many boards end up with. It also shows why the e-signature question is rarely yes or no: it depends on what the resolution is for.

When does a board portal fit better than a signature tool?

E-signature or board portal for circular resolutions
SituationE-signature (Skribble, DocuSign)Board portal (Konsaro)
The board has decided in writing to require signaturesFits: a QES proves identity and signatureVotes are recorded by name and time; the signature question is settled separately
One resolution, motion as a PDFFits, if deadline and discussion option are handled separatelyAlso fits
Regular circular resolutionsEach resolution is its own documentMotion, deadline and result in one workflow; result in the decisions register
A member requests oral deliberationHandled by email or phone"Request discussion" is one of the vote options
Resolution that goes to the commercial registerFits: QES with time stampNo substitute for the signature
Contracts and deeds with form requirementsThe right choiceNo substitute for a signature

How does a circular resolution work in Konsaro?

The chair or the board office starts the resolution with a title, the resolution text, the voters (all active members by default) and a deadline. Members vote yes, no, abstain or request discussion, and every vote is recorded by name and time. The result is recorded as approved, rejected or deferred, with its wording, in the decisions register, and the audit log records when votes are opened, cast, changed and closed. Konsaro does not provide signatures; for a document that needs one, use a signature service. More on decisions and voting, the page for corporate secretaries and security.

What mistakes do boards make with signatures and circular resolutions?

  • Requiring a QES for every resolution because of an old regulation nobody has read in years, then collecting signatures by email.
  • Dropping signatures without checking the regulations or the register requirements for the resolution at hand.
  • Treating a signed PDF as the whole record: no deadline, no note on the right to deliberation, no result sent to everyone.
  • Letting members use the same simple email reply for very different resolutions, so nobody can later say what was approved.
  • Not recording an oral-deliberation request, so the circular route continues after a member has asked for a meeting.

For templates see the circular resolution template, for the member's side voting by circular resolution, and for the full rules circular resolutions of a Swiss board.

Frequently asked questions

Does a circular resolution need a qualified electronic signature?

Not under Art. 713 para. 2 no. 3 CO: in electronic form no signature is required, unless the board has decided otherwise in writing. A QES can still be needed for a filing with the commercial register or because your regulations say so. Have your case reviewed by a lawyer.

When does a QES make sense for a board?

When a form requirement calls for it, when the resolution is an exhibit in an electronic commercial register filing, or when the board has decided to require signatures for electronic resolutions. A QES with a qualified time stamp is equivalent to a handwritten signature (Art. 14 para. 2bis CO).

Can one member stop a circular resolution?

Yes. Any member can request oral deliberation; the matter is then discussed and decided in a meeting.

Is an email reply enough as a vote?

The law does not require a signature for an electronic resolution, so an email can be valid. The risk is documentation: one proposal text, one deadline for everyone and a record of each answer. A portal or a disciplined email template covers that.

Does Konsaro offer e-signatures?

No. Konsaro records every vote by name and time and keeps the result in the decisions register. For documents that need a signature, use a signature service.

Where does Skribble host data?

In Switzerland, according to Skribble's website (checked 29 October 2026). Konsaro stores board data in Zürich, with application servers in the EU.

What about a GmbH, association or foundation?

Art. 713 CO governs the board of directors of an AG. For other legal forms the articles, bylaws and their own statutory rules apply, so check them before you copy the AG process.

Sources

  1. Fedlex: Swiss Code of Obligations, Art. 14, 713, 701c-701e (German) (checked 29 October 2026)
  2. Fedlex: Commercial Register Ordinance, Art. 18 and 20 (German) (checked 29 October 2026)
  3. Fedlex: Federal Act on Electronic Signatures (ZertES, SR 943.03), Art. 2 (German) (checked 29 October 2026)
  4. Skribble: electronic signature Switzerland (checked 29 October 2026)
  5. Skribble: pricing (English) (checked 29 October 2026)
  6. DocuSign: eSignature legality in Switzerland (checked 29 October 2026)
  7. DocuSign: qualified electronic signature (German) (checked 27 October 2026)
Book in under a minuteSee open times instantly

Interested? Let's talk.

We'll walk you through one full board cycle in Konsaro, from the first board book to signed minutes and assigned actions, and answer your questions live.

Book your demo

30-min video call · Phone call · Email