Circular resolution software compared (CH and DE)
—10 min read

Tools for circular resolutions fall into three groups: specialised resolution platforms such as Resolvio; board portals and meeting software with circular resolutions built in, such as Loomion, SoftForge, Sitzungsprofi, ProMeta and Konsaro; and e-signature services such as Skribble. The right group depends on whether you only pass resolutions or run the whole meeting cycle, whether votes are weighted, and whether anything has to be signed.
Who wrote this comparison?
Konsaro, a Swiss board portal, wrote this. We have an interest, so we describe every tool from its own website, say what it does well, and mark what we could not find as "not mentioned", which means only that it was not on the pages we read. Ask each vendor directly before you decide.
What does a circular resolution tool need to do legally?
In Switzerland, the board of directors may pass resolutions in writing, on paper or electronically, unless a member requests oral deliberation (Art. 713 para. 2 no. 3 CO). For an electronic resolution no signature is needed unless the board has laid down otherwise in writing. Resolutions need the majority of votes cast, and the chair has the casting vote unless the articles say otherwise (Art. 713 para. 1 CO). In Germany, written or similar decision-making by a supervisory board is only allowed if no member objects, subject to a closer rule in the articles or rules of procedure (§ 108 para. 4 AktG). We read both provisions on 29 October 2026.
That gives six requirements for any tool:
- A clear proposal with its wording, so everyone decides on the same text.
- A deadline everyone can see.
- An easy way to request a meeting or to object, and a record that it happened.
- Every vote with the person and the time.
- A result that goes into the minutes or the decisions register.
- Your own rules: majorities, weighting and how non-replies count come from the articles and organisational regulations, and the tool has to follow them.
Which tools are on the shortlist?
| Tool | Type | Circular resolutions, per vendor | Signature | Data, per vendor | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Resolvio | Resolution platform | Electronic, by post or hybrid; "100+" resolution templates; a meeting of the members is not needed | "Every participant can sign digitally"; QES details are on a sub-page we did not read | Servers in Germany, European sub-processors | None on the page; free trial offered |
| Loomion | Board portal | "Votes and circular resolutions", evaluated in real time, optionally added to the minutes | "Documents can be signed directly online"; standard not named | ISO-certified data centre in Switzerland; on-premises, Loomion cloud or Azure | On request; demo |
| SoftForge Sitzungsverwaltung | Meeting software in Microsoft 365 | Circular resolutions with their own minutes; deadline and quorum shown in the product | Not mentioned | Runs in your own Microsoft 365 tenant | None on the page; trial, demo |
| Sitzungsprofi | Meeting software | Proposal, deadline, digital vote, result determined automatically | Not mentioned | Servers in Germany | EUR 9.90, 18.90 or 34.90 a month per organisation by number of bodies |
| ProMeta (infotraX) | Committee management system | Deadlines, response status, quorums, documented result | Not mentioned | Developed and operated in Germany | On request; first consultation |
| Skribble | E-signature | Signs finished documents; no resolution process mentioned | Simple, advanced and qualified (ZertES, eIDAS) | Hosted in Switzerland | Per signature, or EUR 23 / 36 per user and month excl. VAT |
| Konsaro | Board portal | Title, resolution text, voters, deadline; yes, no, abstain, request discussion | Votes recorded by name and time; no signatures | Board data in Zürich, application servers in the EU | Free for one board of up to 5 members, without circular resolutions; circular resolutions from Essentials at CHF 199 per organisation and month, annual |
What does each tool do well?
Resolvio
Resolvio is built around the resolution itself. Its page covers electronic circular resolutions, resolutions by post and hybrid forms, and says more than 100 resolution templates are available and that it is hosted in Germany with European sub-processors. If you pass a handful of shareholder resolutions a year, a focused tool is easier to adopt than a portal. What the page does not show is a price. Our own comparison is in Konsaro vs Resolvio.
Loomion
Loomion is a Swiss board portal that lists votes and circular resolutions as a feature, evaluated in real time and optionally added directly to the minutes. It states an ISO-certified data centre in Switzerland and offers three storage options: on-premises, its own cloud and Microsoft Azure. Pricing is on request. See Konsaro vs Loomion.
SoftForge Sitzungsverwaltung
SoftForge runs inside your Microsoft 365 environment (SharePoint Online or on-premises), so no information leaves your tenant, and it gives circular resolutions their own minutes. That suits organisations that already live in Teams and SharePoint. External board members then need access to your tenant. See Konsaro vs SoftForge.
Sitzungsprofi
Sitzungsprofi is the only tool in this list that publishes a full price list: EUR 9.90 a month for up to two bodies and 1 GB, EUR 18.90 for up to five and 2 GB, EUR 34.90 for up to ten and 3 GB, per organisation rather than per person, with a 30-day trial. The page does not say whether VAT is included. Hosting is in Germany. See Konsaro vs Sitzungsprofi.
ProMeta (infotraX)
ProMeta addresses organisations with formal procedures across several bodies: circular resolutions follow defined steps with roles, deadlines, quorums and a response status. The vendor describes development and operation in Germany and several hosting options. Pricing is by consultation. See Konsaro vs ProMeta.
Skribble
Skribble is not a resolution tool. It is the strongest option here for the signature itself: simple, advanced and qualified signatures, Swiss hosting and ISO 27001, with a 14-day trial. On its English pricing page, Team costs EUR 23 and Pro EUR 36 per user and month excluding VAT with annual billing, and QES identification is a one-time fee of EUR 24.50 or CHF 22.50 excluding VAT. Prices change; see circular resolutions with Skribble or DocuSign.
Konsaro
Konsaro runs the circular resolution inside the meeting cycle: the chair or the board office starts it with a title, resolution text, voters (all active members by default) and a deadline. Voters choose yes, no, abstain or request discussion, and each option can be switched off. The result is recorded as approved, rejected or deferred, with its wording, in the decisions register, and every vote is recorded by name and time. The audit log records when votes are opened, cast, changed and closed. Konsaro has no signature function and no vote weighting; that is a limit for shareholder-style resolutions. More on decisions and voting.
Is an e-signature enough for a circular resolution?
For signing a finished document, yes; for the process, usually not. A service such as Skribble makes sure a PDF is signed validly, with a qualified signature if needed. But a signature tool is built for signing, so the deadline, the list of voters, a request for a meeting and the decisions register stay manual. A signature is needed where a rule asks for it: your organisational regulations, or an electronic filing with the commercial register (Art. 18 para. 4 and Art. 20 para. 2 of the Commercial Register Ordinance). Details in the e-signature post.
Which tool suits which body?
| Your situation | Look first at | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Few shareholder resolutions a year, votes weighted by shares, post or hybrid delivery | Resolvio | Built for the resolution; German hosting |
| Association, federation or municipality in Germany with several committees | Sitzungsprofi or ProMeta | Price per organisation (Sitzungsprofi); formal procedures, quorums and proxies (ProMeta) |
| Board that already works in Teams and SharePoint | SoftForge | Runs in your tenant; own circular minutes |
| Board of directors or executive team that meets regularly in Switzerland | Loomion or Konsaro | Circular resolution inside the meeting cycle, result in the same register as meeting decisions |
| Resolution that must be signed or filed with the commercial register | A signature tool such as Skribble, alongside any of the above | A QES with time stamp where the register asks for it |
What does a circular resolution tool cost?
Public prices are rare. Of the seven, Sitzungsprofi publishes a price list in euro per organisation, Skribble publishes seat and per-signature prices, and Konsaro publishes its plans in Swiss francs: Free for one board of up to 5 members with no time limit; Essentials at CHF 199 per organisation and month with annual billing (CHF 240 billed monthly) plus CHF 9 per team seat; Business at CHF 575 (CHF 690 monthly) plus CHF 15 per seat; Enterprise is quoted individually. The others quote on request or offer a trial. Besides the licence, count the secretary's time that today goes into emails, reminders and copying results into the minutes.
Example with the invented Muster AG: five board members, about eight circular resolutions a year, no weighted votes. Konsaro's Free plan (CHF 0, one board, 12-month archive, 1 GB) does not include circular resolutions, so Muster AG needs Essentials at CHF 199 per organisation and month with annual billing. If they also needed a second body, Sitzungsprofi's smallest package covers up to two bodies for EUR 9.90 a month. The numbers matter less than the question of whether the tool can follow Muster AG's regulations.
What should you ask every vendor?
- Can I switch off "request discussion" or see it as a visible, recorded answer?
- How are non-replies and abstentions counted, and can I set a quorum?
- Are weighted votes, proxies or recusals supported?
- Where are data and backups stored, and who are the sub-processors?
- Can I export motion, votes and result as one record for the auditors?
- Is a signature possible, and at which level (simple, advanced, qualified)?
- What happens to the data if we leave?
How do you choose in three steps?
- Decide who decides: the board of directors, the supervisory board, the shareholders or all three.
- Write down your rules: majorities, deadlines, weighting, signature or not, how non-replies count.
- Test two tools with a real resolution, including the case where a member requests a meeting.
Related reading: the circular resolution template, circular resolutions of a Swiss board and Konsaro pricing; data location is on the security page.
Frequently asked questions
Is "circular resolution" the same as "written resolution"?
Yes, in this context. Swiss practice says Zirkularbeschluss or Zirkulationsbeschluss, German practice Umlaufbeschluss; in English both are usually called circular or written resolutions.
Is a circular resolution by email valid?
The law does not rule out electronic circular resolutions. But email often lacks a clear proposal, one deadline for everyone and a clean record of each vote. The risk lies in the documentation, not the medium.
Does a circular resolution need a qualified electronic signature?
In Switzerland, an electronic circular resolution of the board of directors needs no signature unless the board has decided otherwise in writing. A QES is required for electronic filings with the commercial register. Germany and shareholder resolutions have their own rules; have them checked by a lawyer.
Can one member block a circular resolution?
In the sense that they can force a meeting, yes. In Switzerland, requesting oral deliberation is enough; for a German supervisory board, an objection, unless the articles or rules of procedure say otherwise.
Which tool is simplest for a small holding?
With only a few shareholder resolutions a year, a specialised resolution platform is often enough. If the board of directors meets regularly, a board portal that also runs circular resolutions pays off.
Why is Konsaro in a comparison it wrote?
Because it is one of the options a Swiss board will meet. We marked our interest at the top, used vendor websites for every competitor fact and listed where Konsaro is limited: no signatures and no weighted votes.
Sources
- Swiss Code of Obligations (SR 220), Art. 713: fedlex.admin.ch (checked 29 October 2026)
- Commercial Register Ordinance, Art. 18 and 20: fedlex.admin.ch (checked 29 October 2026)
- German Stock Corporation Act, § 108: gesetze-im-internet.de (checked 29 October 2026)
- Resolvio: digital circular resolutions (checked 29 October 2026)
- Loomion: board management software (checked 29 October 2026)
- SoftForge Sitzungsverwaltung (checked 29 October 2026)
- Sitzungsprofi: features and prices (checked 29 October 2026)
- infotraX: ProMeta meeting management (checked 29 October 2026)
- Skribble: e-signature (checked 29 October 2026)
- Skribble: pricing (checked 29 October 2026)



